Perbandingan Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy (PCNL) dan Open Nephorlithotomy Pada Pasien dengan Batu Staghorn : Systematic Review
Main Article Content
Abstract
Introduction: Staghorn stones are one of the most severe forms of urinary lithiasis. They have a nuclear body and at least one calyceal branch. Untreated staghorn stones are associated with recurrent infections, stone growth, significant morbidity, and progressive loss of renal function. This requires further development of appropriate management, both open surgical and endourological. Objective: to compare percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) and open nephrolithotomy in patients with staghorn stones. Methods: This review was conducted in accordance with the requirements outlined in PRISMA 2020. A systematic search for studies to be included in the review was conducted from 20 February 2025 using GoogleScholar, PubMed and SagePub databases using the words: "percutaneous nephrolithotomy", "open nephrolithotomy", and "staghorn". Results: We found six studies comparing PCNL and open stone removal procedures between 2021 and 2025. All of these studies were obtained from Asian countries, one of which was Indonesia. Conclusion: Both open surgery and PCNL are effective options. Although, patients with PCNL generally have a shorter hospital stay, postoperative complications are lower in the open surgery group.
Downloads
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
References
Vázquez-González JC, Romero JJG, Montalvo-Hernández J, Palacios-Rodríguez PM, Mendizabal-Velazquez A, González-Martínez IC, et al. Staghorn renal stones: a review. Int J Res Med Sci. 2023;11(9):1.
Morales AQV, Sol CA, Sánchez JAS, Mireles GM, Mendoza IKM. Staghorn Calculus: A Comprehensive Review of Epidemiology, Clinical, Diagnosis and Treatment. 2023;
Lai Y, Zheng H, Sun X, Lin J, Li Q, Huang H, et al. The advances of calcium oxalate calculi associated drugs and targets. Eur J Pharmacol. 2022;935:175324.
Cyriac R, Pamela D, Manimegalai P, Michael PA. Renal calculi detection using image processing. In: 2022 Second International Conference on Advances in Electrical, Computing, Communication and Sustainable Technologies (ICAECT). IEEE; 2022. hal. 1–4.
Tamborino F, Cicchetti R, Mascitti M, Litterio G, Orsini A, Ferretti S, et al. Pathophysiology and main molecular mechanisms of urinary stone formation and recurrence. Int J Mol Sci. 2024;25(5):3075.
Sharbaugh A, Morgan Nikonow T, Kunkel G, Semins MJ. Contemporary best practice in the management of staghorn calculi. Ther Adv Urol. 2019;11:1756287219847099.
Gadzhiev N, Malkhasyan V, Akopyan G, Petrov S, Jefferson F, Okhunov Z. Percutaneous nephrolithotomy for staghorn calculi: Troubleshooting and managing complications. Asian J Urol. April 2020;7(2):139–48.
Hadibrata E, Suharmanto S, Lania S, Utami D. Stone Free Rate and Complications in Kidney Stone Patients Undergoing Open Nephrolithotomy and Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy (PCNL) Methods. In: International Conference on Medical Science and Health (ICOMESH 2024). Atlantis Press; 2024. hal. 130–5.
Nourian SMA, Bahrami M. Open surgery versus percutaneous nephrolithotomy for management of staghorn calculi. Am J Clin Exp Urol. 2022;10(4):271–6.
Akhtar M, Ullah MS, Lodhi MHK, Aslam N, Zafar Z, Raza QH, et al. Stone Clearance Rate in Patients Treated with Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy versus Open Surgery for the Management of Staghorn Renal Calculi. Pakistan J Med Heal Sci. 2022;16(09):731.
Memon I, Soomro N, Hussain SA, Shah SAR, Rajpar ZH, Sheikh A. Percutaneous nephrolithotomy versus open surgery in patients presenting with renal staghorn stones: A single-center study. Rawal Med J. 2022;47(2):388.
Pimratana C, Wijitsettakul U, Cheunganuwat P. Comparison of the outcomes between ultrasound-guided PCNL in lateral position and open nephrolithotomy for patients with staghorn renal stones. Siriraj Med J. 2021;73(3):191–7.
Faridi MS, Singh AK. Percutaneous nephrolithotomy versus open surgery for renal stonesa prospective randomized study. Pravara Med Rev. 2020;12(4):26–30.
Ermis O, Somani B, Reeves T, Guven S, Pes PL, Chawla A, et al. Definition, treatment and outcome of residual fragments in staghorn stones. Asian J Urol. 2020;7(2):116–21.
Pipal DK, Jain S, Biswas P. A huge staghorn renal stone: Is there still a need for open surgery to protect against further damage to the kidney? A case report. Qatar Med J. 2023;2023(4):30.
Omar HF, Abdelwahab AJ, Morsy ES, Abdelhamied AM. PCNL monotherapy for staghorn stones: Sohag faculty of medicine experience. Sohag Med J. 2020;24(1):41–7.
Viljoen A, Chaudhry R, Bycroft J. Renal stones. Ann Clin Biochem. 2019;56(1):15–27.
Chen Y, Feng J, Duan H, Yue Y, Zhang C, Deng T, et al. Percutaneous nephrolithotomy versus open surgery for surgical treatment of patients with staghorn stones: A systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS One. 2019;14(1):e0206810.
Doykov M, Kostov G, Doykova K. Factors Affecting Residual Stone Rate, Operative Duration, and Complications in Patients Undergoing Minimally Invasive Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy. Vol. 58, Medicina. 2022.
Wagenius M, Borglin J, Popiolek M, Forsvall A, Stranne J, Linder A. Percutaneous nephrolithotomy and modern aspects of complications and antibiotic treatment. Scand J Urol [Internet]. 3 Maret 2020;54(2 SE-Articles):162–70. Tersedia pada: https://medicaljournalssweden.se/SJU/article/view/11694